Salvadorwriter
2004-05-16 18:34:20 UTC
The exchange below is a discussion about the
following article:
Jew Exploits Dying Beatle to His Last Breath, and Beyond
http://www.nationalvanguard.org/story.php?id=1621
[Someone else posted the article on another thread and
gave it a confusing title. So I'm starting a new thread.]
I [Salvador] commented that I saw George Harrison's
Jewish physician, Dr. Gilbert Lederman (the subject
of the article above), on the TV news shortly after
George passed away in late 2001. Lederman remarked
that George had played Hava Nagila on his death bed,
apparently a show of respect for Lederman. After
posting my comment about George playing Hava Nagila,
some woman (presumably a Jewish woman) verbally
assaulted me for mentioning that Lederman is
Jewish.
Here's the exchange.
=====
[Salvador]
Jewish or not[?]...
[Salvador]
[Tom/Donna]
[Salvador]
[Tom/Donna]
completely trivial. "Who gives a flying leap if he's
Jewish or not[?]...You sound terribly nuts."
You started making personal, trivial attacks over
something completely innocent, then you start crying
when I reciprocate. How immature.
[Salvador]
[Tom/Donna]
[Salvador]
[Tom/Donna]
to take off the gloves and make personal,
insulting remarks. Consequently, I shall
reciprocate. You are a lying fecal-head.
You know good and well that point out
Dr. Lederman's Jewish heritage was
completely relevant to my point that
Lederman claimed George Harrison played
Hava Nagila on his death bed. Assuming George
really did play Hava Nagila, the story doesn't
make sense unless you state that Dr. Lederman
is Jewish. I didn't state it as an insult,
merely a fact that is relevant to the
Hava Nagila story. Then you went ballistic.
Your attitude is a perfect example of what is
wrong with Judaism today. Many Jewish people
have no problem whatsoever attacking and
belittling Christianity or Islam, but if a
Gentile so much as utters the word Jew, he/she
is slammed by assholes like you.
Salvador
===
Ordering information for Salvador Astucia's books can be found at
http://www.jfkmontreal.com/raveningwolf/
(About 150 pages from "Lennon book" (558 pages total) can be viewed
at http://www.jfkmontreal.com )
following article:
Jew Exploits Dying Beatle to His Last Breath, and Beyond
http://www.nationalvanguard.org/story.php?id=1621
[Someone else posted the article on another thread and
gave it a confusing title. So I'm starting a new thread.]
I [Salvador] commented that I saw George Harrison's
Jewish physician, Dr. Gilbert Lederman (the subject
of the article above), on the TV news shortly after
George passed away in late 2001. Lederman remarked
that George had played Hava Nagila on his death bed,
apparently a show of respect for Lederman. After
posting my comment about George playing Hava Nagila,
some woman (presumably a Jewish woman) verbally
assaulted me for mentioning that Lederman is
Jewish.
Here's the exchange.
=====
[Salvador]
I don't know if the [National Van Guard]
article [about Dr. Lederman] is completely
true or not, but I recall seeing George's
Jewish doctor on TV a day or two after the
news of George's death was announced to
the world in late 2001.
I recall the doctor (I assume it was Lederman)
saying how he and George had become good
friends. That seems reasonable, under the
circumstances. Then the Yiddish physician said
something quite bizarre. I'm paraphrasing, but
"I brought a guitar to George during his
final hours and asked if he could play
a song for me. So he played Hava Nagila."
Anything's possible, but it's difficult
to imagine George playing a weird song
like Hava Nagila on his death bed.
I don't recall if the doctor said his kids
were present or not, but he definitely
said George played Hava Nagila.
So there seems to be at least a grain of
truth in the article.
Who gives a flying leap if [Dr. Lederman is]article [about Dr. Lederman] is completely
true or not, but I recall seeing George's
Jewish doctor on TV a day or two after the
news of George's death was announced to
the world in late 2001.
I recall the doctor (I assume it was Lederman)
saying how he and George had become good
friends. That seems reasonable, under the
circumstances. Then the Yiddish physician said
something quite bizarre. I'm paraphrasing, but
"I brought a guitar to George during his
final hours and asked if he could play
a song for me. So he played Hava Nagila."
Anything's possible, but it's difficult
to imagine George playing a weird song
like Hava Nagila on his death bed.
I don't recall if the doctor said his kids
were present or not, but he definitely
said George played Hava Nagila.
So there seems to be at least a grain of
truth in the article.
Jewish or not[?]...
Apparently you care a great deal. What are you
trying to hide? Lederman's Jewish heritage was
mentioned in the original article, which is the
topic of this thread. In fact, I recall he said
it himself in the TV appearance where he claimed
George played Hava Nagila on his deathbed.
So if you want to [conceal] Lederman's ethnicity,
you're a bit late. The cat's out the bag. :-)
trying to hide? Lederman's Jewish heritage was
mentioned in the original article, which is the
topic of this thread. In fact, I recall he said
it himself in the TV appearance where he claimed
George played Hava Nagila on his deathbed.
So if you want to [conceal] Lederman's ethnicity,
you're a bit late. The cat's out the bag. :-)
Huh? :| Wha?? :/ ...You sound terribly nuts.
Tell me, Salvador, why do you pretend to be
normal?
Tell me, Salvador, why do you pretend to be
normal?
Is this broad on Valium, or what? :-)
Nope. I just find it absurd that someone would take
another's words and turn it around to suit his own
agenda.
You're the one who made rude remarks over somethinganother's words and turn it around to suit his own
agenda.
completely trivial. "Who gives a flying leap if he's
Jewish or not[?]...You sound terribly nuts."
You started making personal, trivial attacks over
something completely innocent, then you start crying
when I reciprocate. How immature.
[Salvador]
Lederman's Jewish heritage was mentioned in the
original article, which is the topic of this
thread. In fact, I recall he said it himself
in the TV appearance where he claimed George
played Hava Nagila on his deathbed.
So if you want to [conceal] Lederman's ethnicity,
you're a bit late. The cat's out the bag. :-)
original article, which is the topic of this
thread. In fact, I recall he said it himself
in the TV appearance where he claimed George
played Hava Nagila on his deathbed.
So if you want to [conceal] Lederman's ethnicity,
you're a bit late. The cat's out the bag. :-)
What I was trying to say is who the heck cares
what his beliefs are. So now, I guess, you'll
dissect and misinterpret that sentence, too.
what his beliefs are. So now, I guess, you'll
dissect and misinterpret that sentence, too.
Relax, Tom/Donna. Don't get your bowels in an
uproar. No one is out to get you. Nobody wants
to cause you any harm. Obviously you're sensitive
about certain issues, and we all are; but let's
not become paranoid, just because I pointed out
that a particular individual is Jewish.
uproar. No one is out to get you. Nobody wants
to cause you any harm. Obviously you're sensitive
about certain issues, and we all are; but let's
not become paranoid, just because I pointed out
that a particular individual is Jewish.
Pointing it out was unnecessary and had nothing
to do with this lawsuit or anything that I was
saying....
As I pointed out earlier, you were the oneto do with this lawsuit or anything that I was
saying....
to take off the gloves and make personal,
insulting remarks. Consequently, I shall
reciprocate. You are a lying fecal-head.
You know good and well that point out
Dr. Lederman's Jewish heritage was
completely relevant to my point that
Lederman claimed George Harrison played
Hava Nagila on his death bed. Assuming George
really did play Hava Nagila, the story doesn't
make sense unless you state that Dr. Lederman
is Jewish. I didn't state it as an insult,
merely a fact that is relevant to the
Hava Nagila story. Then you went ballistic.
Your attitude is a perfect example of what is
wrong with Judaism today. Many Jewish people
have no problem whatsoever attacking and
belittling Christianity or Islam, but if a
Gentile so much as utters the word Jew, he/she
is slammed by assholes like you.
Salvador
===
Ordering information for Salvador Astucia's books can be found at
http://www.jfkmontreal.com/raveningwolf/
(About 150 pages from "Lennon book" (558 pages total) can be viewed
at http://www.jfkmontreal.com )